FREE tool

Home care agency scorecard

Star ratings alone can mislead. This scorecard weighs how many reviews an agency has, how recent they are and what the agency confirms in writing, so three candidates can be compared fairly. This site does not rank agencies. You enter what you find.

How the score works

The review score is an adjusted rating. An agency with 4 reviews at 5.0 stars tells you much less than one with 120 reviews at 4.7, so the tool pulls ratings from small review counts toward a neutral middle. The more reviews an agency has, the closer the adjusted rating is to the stars you entered. It is a rule of thumb for comparing candidates, not a ranking of the agencies.

The checklist counts what the agency confirms to you directly. Ask for answers in writing, and ask for the Illinois license number so it can be checked with the Illinois Department of Public Health.

Read the full guide first

Our guide on how to choose a home care agency in Chicago explains what to look for in reviews, what to ask, and where to report a problem.

Common questions

Questions people ask

Does this site recommend a home care agency?

No. Benevolent Caregivers is itself a home care agency, so this site does not rank or recommend other agencies. The scorecard works with the ratings and answers you collect yourself.

Where do I find star ratings and review counts?

Agencies usually list them on their Google Business Profile and on senior-care directories. Use the same source for every agency so the comparison is fair.

Is what I type saved or sent anywhere?

No. The scorecard runs in your browser and nothing is stored after you close the page.

Questions about care at home?

Benevolent Caregivers is a family-owned home care agency serving Cook and DuPage counties. Email our team and we will reply.

Email our team